SCIY.Org Archives

This is an archived material originally posted on sciy.org which is no longer active. The title, content, author, date of posting shown below, all are as per the sciy.org records
Marathe's letter: a clarification

Originally posted on sciy.org by Koantum on Wed 11 Mar 2009 10:02 PM PDT  

A certain website "committed to objective, academic, respectful and honest discussions" recently published a letter by a certain Sreehari ("Raja") Marathe.

Marathe writes as though he was a member of the ashram but is actually a "sannyasi" in the Osho movement and a devoted disciple of Amritanandamayi Ma. He writes as though he knows everything about the working of the Ashram Archives yet in fact knows virtually nothing about it. He writes as though Heehs had accepted him as his spiritual guide, not to mention psychiatrist....

When Marathe recently visited Pondicherry, he got so upset by Ranade's approach to conflict resolution (which includes, to the best of my knowledge, having civil and criminal court cases filed against him through proxies) that he tried to make me an accomplice to a retributive action of an even more objectionable nature (if that is possible).

The aforesaid website states that "All posts are copyright (c) their respective authors and may not be used outside this website without prior permission." It has nonetheless published my response to an email by Marathe without my prior permission:

From: Ulrich Mohrhoff
To: Shreehari Marathe
Sent: Thursday, May 7, 2009 1:03:01 PM
Subject: Re: Fw: Many Lives Controversy

Raja,

Being a registered user doesn't make you an editor. After consulting with the other editors, we feel that SCIY is not the appropriate place for your letter.

Best,
Ulrich

Shreehari Marathe wrote:

Hi Ulrich:

I have not figured out as to how to post entries https://www.sciy.org in the correct place (although I am a registered user!), hence I request you to publish this letter in its entirity at the site. Alternatively please send me links telling me how to do it.

Thanks and regards,

Raja

In response to the publication of my email I submitted the following comment:

"Your attack in the preface on all earlier biographers was unwarranted..." or so states the first bullet. The reason why I, as one of the editors of SCIY, found it a waste of time to read beyond this point is that the preface contains no attack whatever on earlier biographers.

As of now, this comment has not been posted at the aforesaid site.

Attachment: